Skottle v. Coleman Dual Burner Stove

jmorin41

jmorin41

Rank III
Launch Member

Enthusiast II

547
Canoga Park, CA 91303
First Name
James
Last Name
Morin
Member #

24855

Now that the new adjustable leg skottle has come out, I've really been contemplating picking one up. I am still using a Coleman dual burner flip open propane stove. The skottle appears to be a step up, but boy are they pricey (I mean an investment). How many of you are still using the Coleman? If so, is there any reason other than price not to purchase? For those that have moved to the skottle, could you go back or is it the best thing since sliced bread?

I'd love to hear some member experiences!
 
I still use my trusty two burner. I’ve been cooking on them for 20 years and have no real interest in trying anything different.

That being said, my dad has a tripod that suspends a big cast iron skillet type deal and it’s come in handy when cooking for larger groups. The idea is kind of the same as the skottle. 90% of the time I camp by myself or with a single friend so usually the Coleman does just fine. If I did more trips with big groups I might start to consider the skottle or something similar.
 
  • Like
Reactions: k9sar, Acolle, Brett L. and 1 other person
i agree on being useful for larger groups. I made my own from a plow disk. It’s neat and I like using it, but I can’t say it would be $300 neat.
 
  • Like
Reactions: k9sar, Downs and JORCAN
I am interested in doing the same. The Coleman is tried and true but in bigger groups we have to have two going and the fire pit becomes a warmer.

I like the idea of being able to cook large amounts of food without multiple pots and pans. But at three bills it's hard to justify.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sparksalot
I had the $ and the want for one and now I wouldn't camp without our skottle...$325 IS a lot, but I literally took away a whole crate of cooking implements (Like pots, pans and cooking utensils), so I end up carrying less and have more room for the dogs lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: k9sar, Mountain Top and DickD1911
I always looked at the skottle and asked is it really worth it for the price? Eventually I went for it and it is worth every penny. Eliminates so much excess cooking gear and it’s great to cook with.
 
  • Like
Reactions: k9sar and DickD1911
I’ve had my Coleman 2 burner since the 90’s. I don't think it’s ever gonna go down and give me a chance to get a new one. I do want a Skottle though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: k9sar
I don’t have a Skottle, no plans to EVER purchase one... however it’s been 2 years since I have packed my Coleman 2 burner stove... portable fire pit and a cast iron DU are all I take any more...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Maverick9110E
We camped with a Coleman 2 burner for many years then 2 years ago got a Skottle...
It makes cooking and cleanup very easy.
The Coleman stays in the camper but seldom comes out anymore.
I would consider leaving the Coleman home but not the Skottle.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrChris
It's good to see the Skottle is valued by those who have picked one up. I also see you can easily get by with the tried-and-true Coleman. I'd go the DIY route, but I have too many unfinished projects. Thanks everyone for your input, this has been super helpful!
 
  • Like
Reactions: k9sar
I have a a Skottle and a two burner. You can make your own skottle Or buy one. You can also take a wok with you.
In the end the skottle is going to take practice and will lend itself to foods that you cook all at once or that will eventually end up as one. Example curry, rice dishes, trash can style breakfast, etc.
the two burners are great for just about everything else and can actually be easier and more forgiving.
But with the skottle you can make lots of food!!
 
I have a two burner Coleman, a three burner(yes three burners), Coleman stove and a homemade skottle. The Coleman's can be used with liquid fuel or a propane converter. All three have their place and purpose. Can't make coffee on a skottle. Pancakes don't work so well either. I made my skottle out of a new plow disk that I welded the hole closed. $34 at a farm store. Welded on horseshoes for handles, $4.95 for a pair. While prowling around at Cabelas, I found a propane fish deep fryer. It looks pretty much like a turkey deep fryer.It has a 6.5 quart pot and a fry basket. It doesn't have legs but sits on a table just perfect. $34.95. Use it at home and camping all the time. And yes with no practice at all you too can burn the crap out of everything on a skottle. Just takes practice to perfect.
 
  • Like
Reactions: k9sar, huachuca and Sparksalot
I am still using a Coleman 425 dual burner. It is light weight and it's squared size makes it very easy to pack in the back of the rig. I checked out the various Skottles at MOORE this year since they peaked my curiosity. The large carry bag and weight of the thing turned me away. Not sure I need the ability to cook for more than 3 or 4 people anyhow.
 
I have 2 Coleman 2 burners. One white gas and a propane model.. I use the white gas in cold weather because propane doesn't seem too like the cold. Mine are fairly new because I seem to have lost the ancient one over the years. I also have 2 lanterns, one of each. However Luci and Goal Zero lamps are now my go to.
 
Fly501 said:
I have a a Skottle and a two burner. You can make your own skottle Or buy one. You can also take a wok with you.
In the end the skottle is going to take practice and will lend itself to foods that you cook all at once or that will eventually end up as one. Example curry, rice dishes, trash can style breakfast, etc.
the two burners are great for just about everything else and can actually be easier and more forgiving.
But with the skottle you can make lots of food!!
Click to expand...


I'm looking for a 14" wok that will fit my Volcano grill.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fly501
I do substantial meals frequently when we camp so I'll stick to a dual-burner and a pots/pans set. The Skottle would be nice for a large group type meals but it just doesn't work for how I cook. Like how i see most cast iron for camping... seems to be more usable in a large group.
 
  • Like
Reactions: peeeeetey
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom