Enthusiast I
Ok OB family, I’m in the hunt for a very good quality axe. Budget is not a concern as I will pay for top quality....what brands should I consider?
Need a good axe!
- Thread starter Scott Marquez
- Start date
-
Guest, UPDATE We went through the site migration runbook and completed all steps. We will need to complete the migration next week, but will leave the forums up for the weekend. A few days after maintenance, a major upgrade revision to the forum site will occur.
Love my Fiskar - and its reasonable. Yes there are better looking and much more expensive axes, but these are workhorses!!
Advocate III
If budget is not a concern I would go for a Gransfors Brüks. I have their hatchet and small Forest Axe, but the one I reach for most now is my Gransfors Bruks Ray Mears Wilderness Axe, usually only available from the Ray Mears Bushcraft Woodlore site. What Mears came up with in collaboration with Gransfors Bruks easily replaces my other two and does a lot more, to boot.
I used to carry a 3lb axe with long handle for camp chores and have found the Gransfors Bruks tools to be so far superior to anything else I've used over the years. So much more can be done with a well made axe head and great steel.
.
Axe choices are likely to be as contentious here as RTTs, bumpers, new vehicle accessories or whatever else. What matters in the end is having a tool you like that is safe, feels good in your hands, does what you need it to, and and is a tool you're proud to keep in shape.
Personally, I like to go with tools and gear I can pass on, as well.
.
I used to carry a 3lb axe with long handle for camp chores and have found the Gransfors Bruks tools to be so far superior to anything else I've used over the years. So much more can be done with a well made axe head and great steel.
.
Axe choices are likely to be as contentious here as RTTs, bumpers, new vehicle accessories or whatever else. What matters in the end is having a tool you like that is safe, feels good in your hands, does what you need it to, and and is a tool you're proud to keep in shape.
Personally, I like to go with tools and gear I can pass on, as well.
.
Last edited:
Protector III
- 14,131
- First Name
- Bjoern
- Last Name
- Eldracher
- Member #
-
20111
- Ham/GMRS Callsign
- DO3BE
That's very well to the point, I could not have said better. You can get a lot of opinions and experiences on equipment here. Which ist good because you can learn from others. And in the end you have to decide for yourself and your needs what is right. Just to add, I like my Fiskars X7. I've been using it for years, it's still top and I'm very happy with it. I think the price-performance ratio is very good.
I second the Gransfors Bruks axes. they are incredibly sharp right out of the gate and they have many options to choose from that have different handle length and head sizes.
Member III
I second the Fiskars, mine has been a great tool and is part of my load out, no matter which vehicle we are in.
Roam Bearded
Rank V
Enthusiast III
I'll vouch for the Fiskar as well. Got the hatchet and the axe and am pleased with how well they've held up and hold their edge.
Advocate I
Third for Gransfors Bruks axes. I have the Small Forester's Axe. Perfect size for when I am doing tree work. I also have a full sized felling axe that I use when I don't care about the edge. Not sure of the brand came home with as it was part of my "Pioneer Tools" setup for the Humvee.
OverLamb24
Rank V
Advocate III
There are many different models out there that do different things. First figure out what you need it for then you can go down the list of makers and their respective offerings. I am however partial to the Scandinavian hand forged varieties.
Member III
- 2,268
- First Name
- Scott
- Last Name
- Viking
- Member #
-
17968
- Service Branch
- Air Force Veteran
I've used various axes over the years and my #1 recommendation is get one with a fiberglass handle! I've had more than one wood handle break but have never had a fiberglass handle break! I have several Fiskar tools including hatches and they all perform well and hold up for a long time.
I have to jump on the fiskars band wagon. I have the camp hatchet, camp axe and splitting maul. The are very light but swing heavy. And if you do manage to break one their customer service is top notch.
Depends what I'm doing.
Splitting lots of wood to set myself up for a season? I'm using a hydraulic log-splitter or, if manual labour is my preference, a heavy maul. It might take a bit more energy to swing, but they will effortlessly split even the largest logs with the right technique.
If I'm just chopping a few logs from the woodpile for the fire in the backyard? I'm grabbing my Fiskars axe, every time -- to echo what many others have said, the toughness, sharpness, usability, and durability of the Fiskars is hard to beat at any price. The head design is fantastic too as it really does a good job of blending a regular axe and a splitting maul. The disadvantage to the Fiskars is the physical size -- it's a bit big to haul around the place in a backpack, for example, because the handle is so long. But, this handle is also partly what makes it so good with it's extra leverage.
Overlanding? I reach for the Estwing Camp Axe. This axe is good at chopping wood -- not the best, but it works good. It excels in felling trees or clearing brush, which is a common occurrence when overlanding, because it's super effective but also light enough to use all day. The Fiskars is a bit long and unwieldy (at least, relative to the Estwing) so it makes it harder to clear brush and I find my Fiskar axe less effective at chopping fallen logs because it is biased to be more of a splitting axe. Whereas the Fiskars is an excellent "around camp" axe, the Estwing is the "Jack of all trades, master of none" axe that I toss in my vehicle for adventures.
Splitting lots of wood to set myself up for a season? I'm using a hydraulic log-splitter or, if manual labour is my preference, a heavy maul. It might take a bit more energy to swing, but they will effortlessly split even the largest logs with the right technique.
If I'm just chopping a few logs from the woodpile for the fire in the backyard? I'm grabbing my Fiskars axe, every time -- to echo what many others have said, the toughness, sharpness, usability, and durability of the Fiskars is hard to beat at any price. The head design is fantastic too as it really does a good job of blending a regular axe and a splitting maul. The disadvantage to the Fiskars is the physical size -- it's a bit big to haul around the place in a backpack, for example, because the handle is so long. But, this handle is also partly what makes it so good with it's extra leverage.
Overlanding? I reach for the Estwing Camp Axe. This axe is good at chopping wood -- not the best, but it works good. It excels in felling trees or clearing brush, which is a common occurrence when overlanding, because it's super effective but also light enough to use all day. The Fiskars is a bit long and unwieldy (at least, relative to the Estwing) so it makes it harder to clear brush and I find my Fiskar axe less effective at chopping fallen logs because it is biased to be more of a splitting axe. Whereas the Fiskars is an excellent "around camp" axe, the Estwing is the "Jack of all trades, master of none" axe that I toss in my vehicle for adventures.
Estwing 26 in. Camper's Nylon-Vinyl Grip Handle Axe E45A - The Home Depot
Estwing - Campers Axe 26 in. Handle Nylon Vinyl Grip - Perfect for anyone that hunts, camps, or farms. Comes with a forged steel, fully polished head and a convenient leather sheath. Grip reduces shock
www.homedepot.com
Member III
- 2,827
- First Name
- Tom
- Last Name
- Houston
- Member #
-
8300
- Ham/GMRS Callsign
- WØNUT Extra
Any axe is quickly useless without a good file and a finishing whetstone, and knowing how to use it. Personally I carry one I got at HF. I tecommend a composite handle. Lack of expertise leads to a lot of cracked axe handles.
Last edited:
Enthusiast III
I’m impressed with my Estwing hatchet. I’d imagine their ax is just as capable. I’ve heard great things about Fiskar. I’d like to get a full size ax and I’m deciding between the two.
Advocate III
- 5,584
- First Name
- Michael
- Last Name
- Rose
- Member #
-
20990
- Ham/GMRS Callsign
- W7FSB
- Service Branch
- US ARMY Retired
If I had to pick just one, it’s be the Estwing. It’s an all-round handier tool. Beyond the stuff I mentioned above, it’s also all steel — I’ve used it to move logs in the fire and even as a spatula to flip steaks on the grill because I forgot my normal kitchen tools at home. And it’s great for the odd tasks — driving tent pegs and such. I wouldn’t use my Fiskar axe for this variety of applications.
But a caveat - the Fiskars axe I have and am comparing my Estwing to is their Splitting Axe; I have the 36” one. They have a few models of axe including the chopping axe which I suspect is closer in performance and general handiness to the Estwing in terms of usability. But, the composite handle still means I’m not using my Fiskars to stir the fire coals or flip steaks!
Enthusiast III
@ChasingOurTrunks Thanks for the breakdown. Truth be told I was leaning towards Estwing. I think you’ve help sure up my decision. Cheers!
Steward I
I carry an old Plumb Victory boys axe I bought at a garage sale. I cleaned it, sharpened it, and made a sheath for it. Good steel that holds an edge, and the original wood handle cleaned up nicely, and looks great with some boiled linseed oil rubbed into it. I also have an old Craftsman carpenter’s hatchet that got the same treatment. The old axes were great steel, and well worth restoring.
