What brand of come-a-long do you use? I’m looking for a good one for my 4Runner? What type of winch rope, cable, synthetic, does it matter?
You want at least a 3 ton rated Come-Along. I haven’t ever seen a come-along with anything other than steel cable or chain used. The come-along body and handle needs to be made out of a cast material (the stamped steel ones are great for stretching fences, but suck in recovery situations; I have never had a stamped steel body come-along survive an actual self recovery).
By the time you get into the price range of a decent come-along, you are approaching winch prices.
The More Power Puller has been manufactured by The Wyeth-Scott Company since 1934. It is the safest and most durable cable puller ever made. This heavy-duty industrial portable ratchet puller/hoist is not the type of light-weight puller found at most home centers or discount stores. It has been...
cspforestry.com
If you decide to go with a winch, stay away from cheap brands (Smittybuilt, Badlands, and low cost Warn). The best winch on the market is anything made by Mile-Marker (especially the military series winches) and high end Warn. Badlands, Smittybuilt and low end Warn winches have poor wiring from the solenoid packs to the winch motor, inferior clutches, and are prone to dirt and water contamination from prolonged periods of unuse.