The best winch for the buck.

  • HTML tutorial

Cold_Front

Rank III
Member

Contributor III

797
Dublin, Ohio, United States
First Name
Brandon
Last Name
Smith
Member #

27956

I’m shopping for a reliable winch with a synthetic rope. The badlands line from harbor freight is where I’m at…just waiting on a sale. I’ve seen some interesting offerings on Amazon. Most of these are likely made in the same factory in China and get a different sticker and dollar amount assigned. What is the best bang for my buck?
 

Cypress

Rank V
Member

Off-Road Ranger I

1,451
Goose Creek, SC, USA
First Name
Allen
Last Name
Murray
Member #

27152

Ham/GMRS Callsign
WRJY639
I've been running a XBull 13k for a little over a year now. It has done everything I have asked it to. IIRC it was $369.

 

Pathfinder I

1,685
Pacific Northwest
First Name
Steve
Last Name
Claggett
Service Branch
U. S. Army
No matter the winch you buy I would recommend you do 3-4 minor pulls with it. Keep duty cycle to 20%, do not over heat the motor. This should break in the motor and gear box and expose any defective parts. The imports can be good units.
 

Junktj

Rank III

Enthusiast III

830
Boone NC
First Name
michael
Last Name
ward
I would suggest watching Amazon warehouse for a good deal. I have 8000 pound mile marker scout series winch I paid under $300 for. The box was beat up, but the winch was perfect.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Billiebob

Billiebob

Rank V
Launch Member

Member III

2,835
earth
First Name
Bill
Last Name
William
Member #

18893

I’m shopping for a reliable winch with a synthetic rope. The badlands line from harbor freight is where I’m at…just waiting on a sale. I’ve seen some interesting offerings on Amazon. Most of these are likely made in the same factory in China and get a different sticker and dollar amount assigned. What is the best bang for my buck?
I've never seen a bad post about the Badlands, and there seem to be a lot of them out there.
I bought a Warn M8000, and love it. But I could have bought 3 Badlands winches.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Desert Runner

MOAK

Rank V
Launch Member

Off-Road Ranger I

2,865
Wernersville Public Library, North Reber Street, Wernersville, PA, USA
First Name
Donald
Last Name
Diehl
Member #

0745

Ham/GMRS Callsign
WRPN 506
Mine is a Superwinch Tiger Shark 9500lb with synthetic line ( external brake ). I just took a look at what they sell for now, yikes, I paid way less than that 7 or so years ago. It has performed flawlessly every time it has been needed. I like sticking with well know reputable brands when it comes to emergency gear.
 

Willys Yella Jeep

Rank V
Member

Builder I

1,578
Castle Rock, Colorado, United States
First Name
Willy
Last Name
Sommer
Member #

40675

Ham/GMRS Callsign
KF0CEO
Service Branch
Army
I’m shopping for a reliable winch with a synthetic rope. The badlands line from harbor freight is where I’m at…just waiting on a sale. I’ve seen some interesting offerings on Amazon. Most of these are likely made in the same factory in China and get a different sticker and dollar amount assigned. What is the best bang for my buck?
Like you, I am looking for a good winch for my jeep. There are a lot out there. But, I have settled on a Warn Evo 8s. Although it can't be operated submerged like it's big brother, I will make the investment. One of the best considerations my friend told me was, why would in buy a 300 dollar winch to recover a 60,000 dollar jeep. Point made.

Willy
 

MMc

Rank V

Influencer II

1,749
San Dimas, Ca.
First Name
Mike
Last Name
McMullen
Member #

18647

I have a Superwinch Tiger Shark 11500 I love mine. They were sold to Westin Automotive about 1 year ago. I need a part and they took care of fast and free. It's used for all kinds pulls and always solid.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Willys Yella Jeep

MuckSavage

Rank V
Launch Member

Member III

2,268
South Jersey, NJ, USA
First Name
Tim
Last Name
McG
Member #

15570

I know it's no longer available but 25 years ago, there were no Chinese winches. I purchased a Superwinch S9000 & have never regretted the purchase. A winch is not something to cheap out on. Think about it.... You're stuck, cold, icey snow is coming down & it's 15 degrees outside. That's no time for winch failure & yes that's a scenario that I've lived through.
 
Last edited:

Countryboy20241

Rank IV
Member

Member II

953
Taylorsville, IN, USA
First Name
Russell
Last Name
Woodhouse
Member #

30472

I’m shopping for a reliable winch with a synthetic rope. The badlands line from harbor freight is where I’m at…just waiting on a sale. I’ve seen some interesting offerings on Amazon. Most of these are likely made in the same factory in China and get a different sticker and dollar amount assigned. What is the best bang for my buck?
I run a smittybilt x20 with synthetic rope that I got for 600 and it has been great so far.
 

Cold_Front

Rank III
Member

Contributor III

797
Dublin, Ohio, United States
First Name
Brandon
Last Name
Smith
Member #

27956

I want to buy a harbor freight but it seems like smittybilt is more for the money. I’d rather have something that’s reliable than cutting corners. If I’m bolting it to the frame it’s becoming a permanent addition to the truck.
 

MOAK

Rank V
Launch Member

Off-Road Ranger I

2,865
Wernersville Public Library, North Reber Street, Wernersville, PA, USA
First Name
Donald
Last Name
Diehl
Member #

0745

Ham/GMRS Callsign
WRPN 506
I read a lot about products all coming from the same factories in China and simply being rebranded. RTTs suffer the same generalization. OVS or any of the other less expensive tents may have come from the same factory as a Tepui or JB tent but the quality is night & day. I come from the chemical coatings industry and most all paint you purchase at Lowes, Walmart or your local mom&pop comes from the same production plant as the Sherwin Williams paint you can buy at a SW paint store. Are they the same paints just rebranded to Dutchboy, Valspar, MAB, Duron, Pratt & Lambert, etc etc.. gawd no. Not even close. So no, a Smitty, or Harbor freight winch is not the same as a Chinese made Warn or Superwinch. My point? Do your research & choose wisely, especially on a piece of kit that could be depended upon to save your life.
 
  • Like
Reactions: El-Dracho

OTH Overland

Local Expert Washington, USA
Member
Investor

Trail Blazer III

4,847
Camano Island, WA, USA
First Name
Dave
Last Name
Ballard
Member #

20527

Ham/GMRS Callsign
N7XQP
Service Branch
Fire/EMS/SAR
I have a Warn 12k Zeon w/ synthetic line on my Ram 3500, and recently purchased a Smittybilt XRC 9500 Gen 3 with synthetic on our Grand Cherokee. I think if I had not purchased and used the Warn first, I might have been happy with the Smittybilt as it works fine so far. But when comparing it side by side with the Warn I can see and feel how much better the Warn operates, its quieter, feels like it has been engineered better. The first indication was the end of the winch line passes thru the drum and is secured by a wedge on the far side on the Warn, but on the Smitty there is little metal tab on the end of the line that is fastened to the side of the drum with a tiny screw. I realize that both winches specify a certain number of wraps of winch line remain on the drum for winching, but i feel much better about the extra efforts that Warn went to in their design. Arguably both winches will likely work fine for many years, and the warn is close to three times the price, but not going to be concerned about that when I need the winch to perform in crappy conditions many miles from civilization. Not planning on replacing the SmittyBilt, but my next winch will be another Warn. Warn has been building winches since 1959 and still assembles them in the USA (Except for the VR series is produced in china) (Warn also does say some of the parts on all their winches come from overseas) First winch I ever bought was a Warn 8274 for my old 74 CJ5, made locally in Seattle. That winch made it onto several Jeeps and was still working on a car trailer when I sold it 30 years later. Of course nothing is built to last that long anymore.


1640194473325.png1640195105874.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: El-Dracho

Xdtitan

Rank V
Member

Pathfinder III

I have a superwinch 9500lb a smittybilt x20 gen2 12,000lb and a warn vr exo 12,000lb bought in that order. The superwinch has been abused for 15 yrs burned one solenoid over that time. The smittybilt is 5 yrs old has had issues with randomly turning on due to wireless frequencies engaging the winch and the free spool clutch system being a pain in the ass not smooth at all sticks and skips. But it works over all and pulls good. The Warn Evo is 4 months old and I have been very happy with it. I have changed the solenoid wiring so that it has a seperate circuit on a switch to power it( lessons learned with the smittybilt) free spool is very smooth and can be engaged under light load. Winch also has smooth operation and pulls very well, great winch for the money would buy another.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MuckSavage

El-Dracho

Ambassador, Europe
Moderator
Member
Supporter
Investor

Inventor I

13,232
Lampertheim, Germany
First Name
Bjoern
Last Name
Eldracher
Member #

20111

Ham/GMRS Callsign
DO3BE
I have been using a WARN winch for many years. It has never let me down. And if there is ever a problem with it, I even get spare parts. I would never buy one of those cheap no name winches. Because as many here have already said, in doubt everything depends on this winch. I want to be able to rely 100% on the winch when I need it and not save money at the wrong end. I can of course also understand if someone can not spend so much money, but then I would rather reach for a used properly overhauled WARN winch (or other brand winch) than a no name product or depending of what you are looking for get an entry level brand winch instead of a pro one. This all for the above reasons.

Something else that is important to me: besides a good winch that you can rely on, what happens around it. Also the assembly, the wiring, the rope, the hook and accessories (winch blanket, snatchblock, schackles, etc.) should be very well done, in good condition and regularly checked and maintained. And always remember, any recovery situation can be dangerous. Think saftey! Be prepared!
 

Dorobuta

Rank II

Enthusiast II

336
Chandler, AZ, USA
First Name
Tim
Last Name
Lovern
check out the YouTube videos on offroad recovery companies. Matt's Offroad Recovery uses nothing but Badlands (Harbor Freight) one of the other channels, they dumped their warns for the Badlands models. None of their Badlands have failed, several of their warns did.

YMMV, but don't write off cheaper as being worse quality. Do the research first.