Influencer I
Electric Winch. Are they necessary for overlanding/touring?
- Thread starter Steve_ohhhhh
- Start date
Advocate III
- 5,584
- First Name
- Michael
- Last Name
- Rose
- Member #
-
20990
- Ham/GMRS Callsign
- W7FSB
- Service Branch
- US ARMY Retired
It’s more of an insurance policy... not necessarily for self recovery, but more as a tool to make other jobs easier.
Boostpowered
Rank VI
Member III
Personal choice, if you like to crank on a hi-lift or come-along all day and keep having to reset thats your choice. Been there done that will never go back to that. If you have a bad back or any bad parts of body I wouldnt recommend it.
I'll take an electric winch over hilift or come along any day. I also prefer scissor jacks off road over hi lifts.
If you have a itty bitty vehicle like a jeep or something else that weighs less than 6k then you may want a hilift , they are made for light vehicles and are much easier and safer to use on them than a mid or full sized truck with gear.
I'll take an electric winch over hilift or come along any day. I also prefer scissor jacks off road over hi lifts.
If you have a itty bitty vehicle like a jeep or something else that weighs less than 6k then you may want a hilift , they are made for light vehicles and are much easier and safer to use on them than a mid or full sized truck with gear.
Member II
I look at all of my recovery gear as an insurance policy. If I or someone else gets into trouble it's there if I need it.
Boostpowered
Rank VI
Member III
I must use my winch a hell of alot more than others on here. I don't consider it a insurance policy, I consider it just another tool in my toolbox to make it easier to get un stuck. There are plenty of other expedient ways to get unstuck, could always tie rope around your front or Rear tires and winch out like that.
Explorer I
Yes, would not leave home without it. I would call it an insurance policy but have gotten to use them so much for myself and others that I call it necessary equipment. That said where to do take your rig? If you stick to freeway and tame gravel roads then you are likely ok without one. If you go to areas with mud/sand or fallen trees then you would benefit from having one (and a chain saw). If you go to the sand you will want some sort of sand anchor to attach to. Winch makes quick(er) work of clearing fallen trees - if you have a chain saw and can make the tree manageable to move. Insurance policy, maybe - you are not going to use it every day or even every trip - but when you need it you will be overjoyed to have it.
Also, if you travel alone then they become more important since you don't have a group to rely on.
We did a ton of trails all over CO, NM, and UT. I used the winch twice. The first time was to rescue a side by side that was sliding off of a cliff and the other was to pull a pickup truck out of a ditch. Needed? No. Piece of mind.... heck yes!
-B
-B
Advocate III
- 5,584
- First Name
- Michael
- Last Name
- Rose
- Member #
-
20990
- Ham/GMRS Callsign
- W7FSB
- Service Branch
- US ARMY Retired
You must get stuck a lot... I too use it as a tool... mostly for clearing trail... occasionally to help a fellow traveler get back on the road, and only once have I ever used a winch to self-recover.
Boostpowered
Rank VI
Member III
I do. have you ever been to the Ozarks? Mostly water crossings and deep mud to contend with. But as a tool ive used it to move trees on the trail, as a farmer i use it move dead cows, helping in breech birth to pull a calf out slowly, pull fence posts and stumps. Rolled a tractor back over. I also live on a very nasty black clay road that gets really bad when it rains so I was having to pull people out after they take a wrong turn, I'm also friends with the local county wrecker service owner every now and then he calls me to come help with recoveries. You can say i kindof know my way around a winch.
Hello... NICU... This is Brokedown from Warn. I have a new line of medical-grade winches.
Boostpowered
Rank VI
Member III
Nah if the winch won't work gotta get in there old school with hands. Wouldn't use a warn if it were free im a Ramsey guy.
Ramsey does not have medical grade winches.... I checked their website..... LOL
-B
Member III
- 2,827
- First Name
- Jim
- Last Name
- covey sr
- Member #
-
16986
- Ham/GMRS Callsign
- none - BREAKER BREAKER HAND HELD CB AND WALKIE TALKIE
It may sound extreme to use a winch for delivery of a calf but when you are alone without help I have seen this done with a come along. The method has saved many breach birth calves from sure death.
Insurance; like all recovery gear it's a case of having it available but driving to avoid having to use anything. The majority of occasions we''ve ever had to use anything has been to help others.
I watch Dr Poole use a jack like device.... the winch actually makes more sense.... But yes, I get it, you got to do what you got to do.
Member III
- 2,827
- First Name
- Tom
- Last Name
- Houston
- Member #
-
8300
- Ham/GMRS Callsign
- WØNUT Extra
The need is not a simple yes or no. It depends on several variables.
1) Where are you located and what types of trails do you run
Are the trails big rocks or mud.?
How difficult are the trails?
2) What is your experience level?
3) Are you normally in a group or run solo?
4) Are you normally on well traveled trails?
1) Where are you located and what types of trails do you run
Are the trails big rocks or mud.?
How difficult are the trails?
2) What is your experience level?
3) Are you normally in a group or run solo?
4) Are you normally on well traveled trails?
Pathfinder III
- 5,200
- First Name
- Kent
- Last Name
- Reynolds
- Member #
-
1632
- Ham/GMRS Callsign
- K6KNT
- Service Branch
- Retired Firefighter
This is kinda like the age old question do I need a HiLift jack.
Its up to the individual to decide what his or her needs are, I personally would never go off road without a winch but thats just me. Level of comfort and knowledge is the most important thing, you can have all the recovery gear ever made stashed in your vehicle but not really know how to use it so its no good. If you have a winch get educated by either trial and error or professional instruction. Local meet-ups are a good place to practice winching, our local group spent three meetings to go over recovery and winching ending with winching backwards.
I use my winch probably two/three times a year, sometimes for self recovery and other time to help out members on a trip. In the end it is a tool that gives me peace of mind that is why I have always had one.
And @Boostpowered mentioned the Ozarks is a place with deep mud and I can tell you from experience you will use your winch.
You never know where your adventure will take you that's why we prepare for every imaginable situation.
Just my ten cents, nothing else.
Member III
Touring? Probably unnecessary insurance policy
Overlanding? More likely to be needed insurance policy.
Overlanding? More likely to be needed insurance policy.
For me it's the weight on the nose as well. Absolutely the worst spot to add weight to a truck with no camper.
You have to be really careful. If you do all of the broverlander mods, you won't have any GVWR left to carry girls in bikinis.
You have to be really careful. If you do all of the broverlander mods, you won't have any GVWR left to carry girls in bikinis.
